Forgot password Extend Verify Contact

48 Is 540 Georgian Bay
Baxter Muskoka P0E 1E0

$469,000
Residential Freehold beds: 3+1 baths: 1.0

Welcome to your dream island retreat!
Photo 1: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 2: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 3: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 4: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 5: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 6: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 7: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 8: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 9: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 10: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 11: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 12: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 13: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 14: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 15: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 16: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 17: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 18: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 19: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 20: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 21: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 22: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 23: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 24: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 25: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 26: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 27: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 28: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 29: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 30: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 31: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 32: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 33: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 34: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 35: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 36: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 37: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 38: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 39: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 40: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 41: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 42: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 43: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 44: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 45: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 46: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Photo 47: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
Status:
Active
Prop. Type:
Residential Freehold
MLS® Num:
X12340464
Bedrooms:
3+1
Bathrooms:
1
Welcome to your dream island retreat! This charming and well-maintained 3-bedroom cottage, complete with a separate bunkie, offers the perfect blend of rustic charm and modern comfort. Set on a beautiful 1/2 acre lot boasting 169 feet of clean, natural frontage, ideal for swimming, boating and soaking up the beauty of Georgian Bay. Nestled among striking cap rock outcroppings, the cottage features multiple decks with breathtaking views & sunsets. Located just 10-15 minutes by boat from Honey Harbour, Midland or Penetanguishene, this rare retreat offers both privacy and convenience. Inside, you'll find cozy, inviting living spaces, fully furnished and insulated for four-season comfort, with a wood stove to keep you warm on cooler evenings. The separate bunkie provides extra guest space, while deeded access to the inner island trail offers walking and biking opportunities. In winter, enjoy direct access to a snowmobile trail crossing the island for year-round adventure. Bunkie shingles redone in 2021. Main cottage re-shingled: 2020 (front side) & 2013 (backside). Whether you are looking for a seasonal cottage or 4-season retreat, this island gem offers a rare combination of comfort, privacy & recreation on the pristine waters of Georgian Bay.
Property Type:
Residential Freehold
Property Sub Type:
Detached
Home Style:
Bungalow
Approx. Age:
16-30
Total Approx Floor Area:
700-1100
Lot Size:
.50-1.99
Depth:
257'
Frontage:
169'
Lot Shape:
Rectangular
Topography:
Flat, Rocky
Direction Faces:
South
Bedrooms:
3+1
Bathrooms:
1.0
Water supply:
Other
Kitchens:
1
Bedrooms Above Grade:
3
Bedrooms Below Grade:
1
Kitchens Above Grade:
1
Rooms Above Grade:
8
Zoning:
SR
Heating type:
Other
Heating Fuel:
Wood
Fireplaces:
1
Foundation:
Piers, Wood
Roof:
Asphalt Shingle
Basement:
None
Fireplace Features:
Wood Stove, Living Room
Fireplace/Stove:
Yes
Alternative Power:
None
Garage:
None
Garage Spaces:
0.0
Other Structures:
Out Buildings
Parking Features:
None
Parking Spaces:
0
Total Parking Spaces:
0.0
Rural services:
Cell Services, Electricity Connected
Family Room:
No
Possession Details:
Flexible
Pool:
None
Link:
No
HST Applicable To Sale Price:
Included In
Assessment:
$238,000
Assessment Year:
2024
Taxes:
$2,057.51 / 2025
Assessment:
$238,000.00 / 2024
Georgian Bay
Baxter
Muskoka
Island, Wooded/Treed, Waterfront, Marina, Lake Access, Clear View
Countertop Range, Guest Accommodations, Water Heater Owned
Deck, Privacy
Unknown
All furniture: dining set, couch, love seat, kitchen stools, beds, dressers, outdoor furniture (with exception of exclusions listed below), cutlery, glasses, plates and kitchenware.
Cedar blanket box, single wicker chair, wicker, tables and wicker stand, 2 rattan tub chairs, 2 green muskoka chairs.
Wood, Vinyl Siding
169'
Dock, Trent System
Direct
Clean, Natural
Owned
North
Bay, Clear, Water, Trees/Woods, Panoramic
Direct
By Water
Georgian Bay
Bay
Not Applicable
Private
Floor
Type
Size
Other
Main
Living Room
14' × 13'5"
Main
Dining Room
13' × 10'
Main
Kitchen
13'5" × 12'
Main
Bedroom
12' × 11'
Main
Bedroom 2
12' × 8'4¾"
Main
Bedroom 3
8' × 7'
Main
Other
15'5" × 11'5"
Floor
Ensuite
Pieces
Other
Main
No
-
8'4¾" x 5'
Utilities Gas:
No
Utilities Hydro:
Yes
Utilities Water:
No
Water Supply Types:
Lake/River
Sewers:
No
Sewage:
Grey Water
Special Designation:
Unknown
Sewers:
Other
Air Conditioning:
None
Central Vacuum:
No
Seller Property Info Statement:
No
Date Listed:
Aug 12, 2025
Original Price:
Previous Price:
  • Photo 1: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Welcome to your dream island retreat!
  • Photo 2: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Well-maintained 3-bedroom, 1-bath cottage + bunkie
  • Photo 3: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Set on a beautiful 1/2 acre lot on Georgian Bay
  • Photo 4: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Boasting 169 feet of clean, natural frontage
  • Photo 5: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Ideal for swimming, boating & soaking up the views
  • Photo 6: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Multiple decks with breathtaking views & sunsets
  • Photo 7: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Just 10-15 minutes by boat from Honey Harbour
  • Photo 8: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Cottage re-shingled: 2020 (front) & 2013 (back)
  • Photo 9: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Fully furnished & insulated for 4-season comfort
  • Photo 10: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Enjoy water views right from your living room
  • Photo 11: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Spacious living room for entertaining
  • Photo 12: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Photo 12 of 47
  • Photo 13: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Open concept living, dining, kitchen
  • Photo 14: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Dining room with space for 6-8 seater table
  • Photo 15: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Photo 15 of 47
  • Photo 16: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Wood stove to keep you warm on cooler evenings
  • Photo 17: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Large kitchen with plenty of prep space
  • Photo 18: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Photo 18 of 47
  • Photo 19: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Window overlooking backyard
  • Photo 20: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Door to bathroom
  • Photo 21: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Hallway to bedrooms 1 and 2
  • Photo 22: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Spacious primary bedroom, with door to front deck
  • Photo 23: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Primary bedroom
  • Photo 24: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Primary bedroom
  • Photo 25: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Bedroom #2
  • Photo 26: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Bedroom #2
  • Photo 27: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Cozy Bedroom #3
  • Photo 28: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Cozy Bedroom #3
  • Photo 29: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    3-piece bath
  • Photo 30: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    3-piece bath
  • Photo 31: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    3-piece bath
  • Photo 32: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Separate bunkie provides extra guest space
  • Photo 33: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Bunkie provides plenty of extra sleeping
  • Photo 34: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Shingles on bunkie replaced in 2021
  • Photo 35: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Photo 35 of 47
  • Photo 36: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Photo 36 of 47
  • Photo 37: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Photo 37 of 47
  • Photo 38: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Large back deck off kitchen, excellent for BBQ'ing
  • Photo 39: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Private backyard
  • Photo 40: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Photo 40 of 47
  • Photo 41: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Deeded access to the inner island trail
  • Photo 42: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Walk or bike around the entire island!
  • Photo 43: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Photo 43 of 47
  • Photo 44: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Enjoy the views from your new island retreat!
  • Photo 45: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Located on the pristine waters of Georgian Bay
  • Photo 46: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Photo 46 of 47
  • Photo 47: 48 Is 540 Georgian Bay in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12340464
    Floor plans
Listed by ONE PERCENT REALTY LTD.
Data was last updated August 15, 2025 at 04:15 AM (UTC)
Area Statistics
Listings on market:
90
Avg list price:
$898,500
Min list price:
$425,000
Max list price:
$4,895,000
Avg days on market:
71
Min days on market:
1
Max days on market:
538
These statistics are generated based on the current listing's property type and located in Baxter. Average values are derived using median calculations. This data is not produced by the MLS® system.
powered by myRealPage.com